A buyer’s guide from the makers

Tallow got popular. Then the fakes showed up.

You read labels. So here are 6 tricks to watch for, and one simple test that catches each one. Use it on every tallow brand. Even us.

1,700+ reviews · 100,000+ customers

Shop the balm $44.95

No. 1

The Mystery Sludge

✕ Not TryTallow A competitor label: water is ingredient 1, tallow is 5th of 41, two yellow dyes added

A “tallow” lotion we bought at a store. This is not our product. Ours has 5 ingredients, and tallow is #1.

You want tallow because it’s simple and natural.

Now flip over a “tallow” jar from the store. Water. Fillers. A list over 40 ingredients long. Even yellow dye. Sometimes tallow is 4th or 5th.

Why it matters: You wanted simple. You got mystery sludge with “tallow” on the front.

Tip

The first ingredient is most of the jar.

Ask them

“Why isn’t tallow first?”

Our answer

Tallow is first. Then beeswax, raw honey, olive oil, and essential oils. That’s all 5. No water. No dye. No mystery.

Shop the 5-ingredient balm

No. 2

The Ghost Kitchen

A factory line filling identical white jars

Some brands don’t make their own balm. A factory makes it for dozens of brands. Same balm, different label.

Why it matters: No one at the brand ever sees it made. So who’s checking what goes on your skin?

Ask them

“Do you make it yourselves?”

Our answer

Yes. We make every batch by hand in Neptune, NJ. We post videos of it. We were the first tallow brand at Sprouts.

Shop NJ-made balm

No. 3

The Bleach Job

Some tallow is bleached until it’s pure white with no smell. What’s left is white grease in a tallow jar.

Why it matters: You pay for tallow’s vitamins, and your skin never gets them.

Ask them

“Is your tallow bleached?”

Our answer

Never. We melt it low and slow to keep vitamins A, D, E, and K. That’s why ours is cream colored. We test every batch.

No. 4

The Trend Chaser

You’ve heard tallow is great for your skin. So have they.

So they buy cheap tallow from a factory overseas. No farm. Low standards. Made for pennies. Then they put “premium” on the jar and charge you full price.

Why it matters: You pay for the tallow you heard about. You get balm made for pennies.

Ask them

“What country is it from?”

Our answer

The USA. 100% grass-fed, from American family farms. It’s on the label.

Shop US-farm balm

No. 5

The Fake Small Brand

Fake “small” brands are everywhere now. A big company dresses up as a family shop. The grandma story is made up. Sometimes the founder photo is AI.

Why it matters: If they lie about who they are, why trust what goes on your skin?

Ask them

“Who are you?”

Our answer

We’re Kevin and Rey. Google us. We made this to fix our own skin. Email us and a real person writes back. Usually Honey. (Yes, that’s her real name.)

Shop Kevin & Rey’s balm

No. 6

The Tiny Jar

Their 1.7oz jar versus our 4oz jar, compared per ounce

Some brands shrink the jar but keep the price. Then they hide the size in photos.

Why it matters: You pay more per ounce and run out sooner.

Tip

Divide the price by the ounces.

Ask them

Nothing. Just do the math.

Our answer

4 full ounces. One jar lasts about 2 months. That’s about 75¢ a day. Bundles bring it down even more. And our photos always show a hand, so you can see the size.

Shop the full 4 oz

The verdict

Now test us.

6 tests. 6 straight answers. Real tallow for soft, calm skin, and 60 days to try it risk-free.

1Tallow is ingredient #1Just 5 ingredients. No water, no dye
2We make it, in Neptune, NJPoured by hand in small batches
3Never bleachedVitamins A, D, E, K kept in
4Grass-fed, from US farmsPrinted on the label
5Real founders, real repliesKevin, Rey, and Honey
64 full ouncesLasts about 2 months

Find us in stores at

100,000+: customers
1,700+: reviews
450+: stores
60 days: money-back guarantee

Our signature balm

Grass-Fed Tallow Balm

$44.954 oz glass jar · lasts about 2 months

Get the 4 oz balm Buying more? Bundles start at $4/oz

60-day money-back guarantee
Free shipping on orders over $30

Tallow Balm 4 oz$44.95 · 60-day guarantee

Shop the balm